Haste wastes Japanese militarism- the Manchukuo fiasco of 1929. As far as I know, power is mostly about draw weight. That of course is the Welsh or English longbow.The weapon was in widespread use among the tribes of Wales and the English were quick to utilize the weapon in their own armies and battle tactics. And the draw weight only matters if the archer has the strength to draw it. Sep 4, 2013. The English longbow was a powerful medieval type of longbow (a tall bow for archery) about 6 ft (1.8 m) long used by the English and Welsh for hunting and as a weapon in warfare. Samurai Bow explores the violence, beauty and reverie which surround the Samurai's earliest weapon. Archery societies were set up across the country, each with its own strict entry criteria and outlandish costumes. release weight/speed would be a better indicator of power. late game its 26 range vs 20 range. VS 1-Eat it Rhodri! That being said the best bow for this is the Recurve Bow, used primarily by the Mongols and early Turks. Yumi bends much more than the longbow during the draw though, it is also shaped into recurve bow and it is on average thinner so they are not exactly the same. Compared to the longbow this is pretty amazing, as the longbow is already longer than many archers are tall. The English longbows recovered from the Mary Rose had an average length of 1.98 meters. It is the intention of this short May 12th, 2020 - War Bows Longbow Crossbow Posite Bow And Japanese Yumi Ebook Loades Mike Au Kindle Store' 'pound Bow Vs Longbow Who Really Wins The Fight May 29th, 2020 - The Elements That Make The Longbow And Pound Bow Affect How These Two Tools Operate Let S Look And The Material Position Of Longbow Bows perform according to their surroundings, to the skill of the person shooting it, etc. Mausmane Member. The Japanese Longbow (Yumi) A short paper explaining its asymmetry presented by Graham Ashton Date: September 1997 Scope There are several different stories in current circulation that try to explain the asymmetry of the Japanese Longbow. There is no "best." They are decent in colonial but after that it is better to use muskets + hussars. Battle. The English longbow vs The Yumi longbow. 1. As far as I know, power is mostly about draw weight. Come join our discussions, post your own battles and kick some ass! both went through armour at short range and penetrated deep into straw representing horses. I'm not a weapons buff, so I don't know enough about the technical aspects of each weapon to comment on it, but it would seem to me that the effectiveness of a bow in the overall context of a battle comes down to numbers. The crossbow is less efficient compared to the longbow in terms of shooting frequency. Yumi vs longbow would seem to depend more on actual draw weights and type of arrows used but if Yumi had equal as longbow it becomes more about what you want to accomplish. 2-Asym bows are so frikken wonky in this game. level 1. Its length ranges from 212 cm – 245 cm (6 ft 11 in – 8 ft). Thanks to its unique shape it can be fired comfortably from horse back and may have been designed with this in mind. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Below a draw chart for a Turksihs composite bow vs a longbow. R2: Now one of the Yumi longbow's biggest advantages is having a significantly more complex design than the English, as the curvature takes a significant amount of strain away from the tips of the handle. A longbow is not significantly recurved.Its limbs are relatively narrow so that they are circular or D-shaped in cross section. The Roman Factions: Legionary Cohort 2. A 150lb Italian yew bow with a very hard arrowhead shooting at a steel breastplate at twenty yards. This allows those with less experience to aim and shoot a crossbow. A longbow is a type of bow that is tall – roughly equal to the height of the user – allowing the archer a fairly long draw. Recreational archery soon became extravagant social and ceremonial events for the nobility, complete with flags, music and 21 gun salutes for the competitors. By European pride I would say the Longbow. ‘War Bows’ by Mike Loades Bow Vs Musket ~ Easton remarked that the book a fourpart survey of the English longbow crossbow composite bow and Japanese Yumi is based on the latest scholarship I find the book a mixed bag To some degree Loades’ does push back against pop culture myths such at the image of archers launching accurate arrow storms from their A 150lb Italian yew bow with a very hard arrowhead shooting at a steel breastplate at twenty yards. Round 3: Ease of use when using on horseback and on foot. Longbowmen have only 1 card that increases range, I would say longbowmen in the early game and yumi in the late game. Here is some more test data with comments. Yumi vs. European Longbow (Asym vs. Longbow) Thread starter Mausmane; Start date Sep 4, 2013; Status Not open for further replies. The Yumi is easily the world’s longest bow. Today, there are three main types of yumi bows; the synthetic yumi made of carbon fiber and fiberglass, the authentic bamboo yumi (the standard one) and lacquered bamboo yumi. The effective range of a As a military weapon that's very important, as is the fact that it is more hardy. Set bonuses and other info go here. Japanese Yumi' 'mongol posite bow vs english longbow history forum May 18th, 2020 - oh i can t tell you how many threads i encountered on the internet stating how superior the mongol posite bow is i seen some threads go as far as stating that mongol Now the Yumi seems to have the curvature down, but as I have not performed archery on horseback before, I can't speak for the convenience. Many analysts have compared the crossbow and the longbow, detailing both of the tools and their benefits. It shoots Japanese arrows called ya. Yumi's are interesting and they did the job they needed to do, but those jobs were pretty different from the longbow during its peak. #3. And the draw weight only matters if the archer has the strength to draw it. Founded in 2006, Historum is a history forum dedicated to history discussions and historical events. It is … Missing information. level 1. So I'd say R1 goes to the English. share. The longbow arrow deflection they keyed in on is simply a spine issue. Report Save. Why draw weight? The "How-To" Gun Girl Emily Houston Monroe got to shoot with a master of Japanese longbow (kyudo). The Yumi Archer is a Japanese archer with a high attack that is good against heavy infantry and light cavalry, and has a very long range. Why were the Japanese so brutal to the Chinese? Thread starter #1. Nothing can match its range and power. TheYumiwas an Ancient Japanese bow. Our community welcomes everyone from around the world to discuss world history, historical periods, and themes in history - military history, archaeology, arts and culture, and history in books and movies. Longbows may be the most overrated unit in the game. R3: Most Eastern originated countries and cultures prize horseback archery and its obvious why. Mar 22, 2013 - Pound for pound, which bow whas most effective, the weapon of the elite, or the weapon of the common man? Jun 29, 2011. Sep 4, 2013 #1. The majority, or at least a large number of the arrows, would have penetrated slightly into the armor, and then lodged there. Secondly, a longbow arrow didn't have to kill, wound or even penetrate the armor to become an important factor on the battle field. Yumi bends much more than the longbow during the draw though, it is also shaped into recurve bow and it is on average thinner so they are not exactly the same. A skilled squad can take out an entire battalion if they keep their mobility high and aim sharp. '09 Match Of Death Winner My elorating Never interrupt your enemy when he is making a mistake.